The film Brothers is a captivating portrayal of one of the most controversial periods in Czech history - the Cold War era. Directed by Tomáš Mašín, the movie tells the story of brothers Josef and Ctirad Mašín, played by Oskar Hes and Jan Nedbal, respectively, who became symbols of resistance against the Communist regime in Czechoslovakia. The narrative is set during a time when the Mašíns, inspired by their father, a hero of the anti-Nazi resistance, formed a resistance group that carried out numerous violent acts against the regime, leading to widespread investigation and pursuit.
Opinions on the Mašín brothers' actions are deeply divided in the Czech Republic. Some celebrate them as heroes who fought against communism, while others criticize their use of violence against civilians. There is also a group of people who view them as mere murderers, a viewpoint strongly supported by the Communist Party at the time.
Personally, I recognize the complexity of this issue and have read extensively to form a comprehensive understanding of the Mašín brothers. However, I choose to keep my opinion to myself.
Regarding the film itself, it is a technically well-crafted work that found its supporters and detractors even before its premiere and is sure to continue dividing audiences. Director Tomáš Mašín has created a film that avoids one-sided defenses and discussions, instead offering a cross-generational perspective. The movie is intensely compelling at times, addressing themes that continue to provoke debates today.
Screenwriter Marek Epstein is among the best Czech scriptwriters, and despite several challenges, he has managed to create a strong and convincing script. The film has been well-received both in the Czech Republic and internationally, and is certainly worth watching.
To add more intrigue to the film, director Tomáš Mašín is a distant relative of the Mašín brothers. His great-great-grandfather was the brother of the Mašín brothers' grandfather, making them his great granduncles.
Furthermore, Josef Mašín personally guided the director along the route of their escape through former East Germany. Although the director never met Ctirad Mašín, who has since passed away, this personal connection added depth to the film's portrayal of the brothers' journey.